Hi Andy,
I note you said trailerable?........So I am assuming that you have in mind that you will trail your boat home in the winter, but leave her on a mooring during the season? The reason I am asking for clarification is that as I am sure you are aware, there is a world of difference between a trailer sailor, and a trailerable sail boat.
Well for now let's assume that it is as I am surmising and you aren't in fact wanting a trailer sailor, firstly I would concur with just about everything that has been said previously, and would only add that my inclination would be to go for the 21, just on the grounds of easier management on and off the trailer, and that for your budget, you will like as not get a better 21, than a 235. plus if you have the budget for a 21 and a 235 at a stretch, I would say that the difference could be put to good use on the 21?
I sail out of North Devon, and I can tell you that taking the ground is what we do, no choice really, a boat that wont take the ground around here is a bit of a liability to be honest. I am a newcomer to Parker Seals etc. and have just bought a Seal 22, as it happens my moorings are in soft clean sand, and I am happy to let "Morveren" take the ground and just lean over a bit. If I was spending the night aboard, I would look for fairly deep soft mud, or hard sand and use her legs, as long as the tide isn't likely to tear in around her at a great rate of knots. But I digress! I have had all kinds of boats here in N. Devon, such as Swift 18, E-Boats, Westerly bilge keelers (a couple), and I think that as long as you choose your ground a bit you are not likely to come to grief in a P21.
Now as I said, I am a newcomer to these boats, and because of that my opinion may not carry much weight, but I just wanted to offer my support for your thinking on the matter really. In mitigation, I have been sailing in N. Devon for about 35 years so far, and drying out all that time without loss or damage. Go for it Andy.
Cheers, Ray. (I will skulk orf back to the 22 forum now)[:D]
Seal 22 MK3 "Morveren" Number 384
(the last one built by John Baker)
Seal 22 MK3 "Morveren" Number 384
(the last one built by John Baker)