Hello Jeremy,
Welcome to the forum and congratulations on your choice of boat. The P235 sails very sweetly so, if you’re experiencing excessive weather helm, something is definitely wrong! The helm should be one-finger light and able to be trimmed neutral or with slight weather helm. Of course, like most boats, weather helm increases with excessive heel, but then so does leeway, so that is to be avoided. The boat sails upwind best at heel angles much less than those that induce excessive weather helm or broaching owing to the rudder losing grip. If you felt the need to reef, was that because heel was becoming excessive? Or did you encounter excessive weather helm at low/moderate heel angles? (The standard bulkhead compass also indicates heel angle, which is useful. You should find she goes well if you limit heel to about 20 – 25 degrees.)
If the latter, perhaps the mast is raked excessively, as Gary suggested. Alternatively, perhaps the boat was trimmed down by the bow too much – lots of weight in the forepeak/chain locker? It sounds like your problem was quite marked, though, and it would be surprising if either of those were to cause such a large weather-helm problem.
If the primary problem was excessive heel – with the weather helm just being a symptom of heeling – the set of the sails (both of them) is the first consideration. If they’re original and anything like the ones my boat had from 2002, they will almost certainly be stretched out of shape and causing a lot of drag and heel. If you’re having trouble hardening the main outhaul, that will also contribute significantly. Like Gary, I too can recommend bringing the outhaul down to a clutch. You’ll need to haul hard on all the controls to flatten the sails as much as possible. You said you hardened the main halyard and backstay; was it successful in depowering the mainsail? With my old mainsail, I was unable to flatten it properly, even using extra mast pre-bend (ensuring the cap shrouds are tensioned correctly is also important). I realised I needed to replace it. Bad news, of course. (However, if you’re quick, the good news is that this is the cheapest time of year to order new sails!)
Without much crew weight on the windward side (the effect of which can be very significant), you’ll probably usually find you’ll want to put in the first reef in the low end of a F4. As you say, reefing in 10kts is not normal. How certain are you of that wind speed?
You mentioned the possibility of the rudder not being fully down. That will certainly make the helm feel very heavy (unbalanced) but it won’t, in itself, cause weather helm – i.e. the need to bring the helm to weather to maintain a straight course.
I shared your dislike of not have a traveller, so I fitted one and I certainly recommend it. It allows much better control of the mainsail and of heel angle, and makes beating to windward even more fun (if you like that sort of thing, which I do!).
Anthony Russell
235/02 Sea Wyche
Anthony Russell
235/02 Sea Wyche